🍔 The Butta Burger Review | Reggie's Tavern
Today we're at Reggie's Tavern, a Chicago-themed dive bar where I stopped in to watch the Lions and Bengals games.
Now, being a Lions fan in a Chicago bar can be a dangerous game. Luckily, the Bears weren't playing, so nobody threw me out into the parking lot for cheering at the wrong time.
And honestly? Before we even talk about the burger, the people here were awesome. Super welcoming, super friendly. The kind of place where five minutes after walking in, you feel like you've been drinking there for years.
But enough about making friends.
I've been wanting to try the Butta Burger for months. I've heard about it, seen photos, and every time I was near Reggie's, something came up.
This time, I grabbed a buddy, made the trip, and finally got my hands on one.
The question is...
Was the Butta Burger worth the wait, or was I chasing a delicious lie?
Appearance - 4/5
The second this burger hit the table, I knew exactly what it wanted to be.
This thing wasn't trying to reinvent burgers.
It wasn't stacked six feet high with onion rings and sparklers.
It was a straight-up smash burger with two beautifully crusted patties that looked like they had been blessed by the gods of cholesterol.
My mouth immediately started negotiating terms with my stomach.
Bun - 9/10
Can we give the bun some respect?
This thick sesame seed bun showed up ready for work.
No collapse.
No soggy disaster.
No "halfway through the burger and now I'm holding meat salad" situation.
This bun held together all the way to the finish line like a veteran offensive lineman protecting the quarterback.
Elite performance.
Meat - 25/30
This category was a roller coaster.
The char on these patties?
Outstanding.
Absolutely phenomenal.
The crispy edges had me making noises that should probably remain private.
Every smash burger fan knows those crunchy edges are where the magic happens, and this burger had plenty of them.
But then...
We ran into a problem.
Outside of all that glorious char, the beef was surprisingly bland.
It felt like the seasoning truck got lost on the way to Reggie's.
A little salt would've gone a long way.
The texture? Great.
The char? Amazing.
The flavor? Kind of took the day off.
Cheese - 9/15
The cheese on this burger reminded me of Bigfoot.
People claim it's there.
I've seen blurry evidence.
But I can't prove it.
Seriously, where was the cheese?
You've got a half-pound smash burger masterpiece here. I wanted molten cheese lava flowing down the sides.
I wanted cheese stretching halfway back to the kitchen.
Instead, it felt like someone whispered the word "cheese" near the burger and called it a day.
Veggies - 9/15
The tomatoes and onions were sliced so thin they qualified for witness protection.
They were technically on the burger.
I checked.
Twice.
They didn't really add much flavor, but they also didn't get in the way.
The pickles, though?
The pickles came to play.
They added a nice pop of flavor and probably worked harder than anybody else in the vegetable department.
Sauce - 6/10
This category hurts.
Because this burger was one good sauce application away from becoming something special.
The sauce was supposed to be a Chicago-style smash burger sauce, but I really didn't get much dill or heat.
Mostly it tasted mayo-based.
And here's the bigger issue:
There wasn't enough of it.
Listen, if you're going to put sauce on a burger, commit to the bit.
I should not be searching for sauce like I'm looking for a missing person.
Give me enough to make a mess.
Give me enough to stain my shirt.
Give me enough to regret wearing a light-colored hoodie.
Messiness - 3/5
This burger stayed surprisingly clean.
A little juice escaped, but nothing crazy.
Normally, I'd want sauce and melted cheese all over my hands.
That sounds disgusting to normal people, but burger reviewers know that's how greatness often arrives.
Unfortunately, the lack of cheese and sauce kept this thing pretty tidy.
Which is great for my laundry.
Not so great for my taste buds.
Burgerness - 8/10
Oh yeah.
This felt like a burger.
Heavy in the hand.
Big meaty bite.
Crispy edges.
Every bite screamed, "Yep, that's a burger."
If the beef itself packed more flavor, we'd be staring down a perfect score here.
Final Verdict - 73 Patty Points
Honestly?
I thought this was going to score higher.
The frustrating thing about the Butta Burger is that you can see exactly how close it is to greatness.
The bun is fantastic.
The char is fantastic.
The structure is fantastic.
And then the burger leaves points sitting on the table because of the cheese, sauce, and lack of seasoning.
It's like watching a team move the ball all the way down the field only to kick a field goal from the 2-yard line.
You appreciate the effort...
But you also know what could've been.
🏆 Favorite Part
The bun.
This bun deserves a game ball.
🤦 Least Favorite Part
The lack of cheese.
I've had stronger cheese presence on burgers that forgot cheese entirely.
🍔 Would I Recommend It?
If you're already in the neighborhood?
Absolutely.
Give it a shot.
If you're planning a 45-minute pilgrimage purely for this burger?
I'd probably pump the brakes.
Final Thoughts
The Butta Burger had some knockout moments.
Those crispy smash burger edges were outstanding.
The bun was one of the best parts of the whole experience.
But the lack of seasoning, cheese, and sauce kept this burger from reaching its full potential.
Final Score: 73 Patty Points.
A good burger.
A fun burger.
A burger with all-star potential that got caught looking ahead to next week's game. 🍔🏈

